Coloring

September 1, 2009

The Published Word

Filed under: Uncategorized — unrealnature @ 7:46 am

I think this little snip from an article, The Unlikely Writer by Elizabeth Gudrais in Harvard Magazine (Sept/Oct 2009) about surgeon/writer Atul Gawande is a nice description of the benefit of writing a blog. In addition to agreeing with what he says, I would add that I write as much for myself as anybody else. I find it stimulating and enjoyable to have to pursue topics, and then to think about what I’ve posted throughout the rest of the day. I would not do this without the mild prompting of this blog. Anyway, here is the quote:

… Once a college sophomore with little interest in literature, Gawande now says he thinks in stories and feels a compulsion to write. In fact, he recommends that everyone do a bit of writing. “It makes no difference whether you write a paper for a medical journal, five paragraphs for a website, or a collection of poetry,” he said during a 2005 HMS commencement speech:

…by putting your writing out to an audience, even a small one, you connect yourself to something larger than yourself….An audience is a community. The published word is a declaration of membership in that community, and also of concern to contribute something meaningful to it.

[ … ]

On the desk in his office at the Brigham is a framed copy of Sylvia Plath’s poem “The Surgeon at 2 a.m.” She describes a patient’s innards as “tubers and fruits/Oozing their jammy substances.” From the surgeon’s perspective, she writes: “I worm and hack in a purple wilderness.” Gawande notes that Plath, not a surgeon, nevertheless got things just right. “That,” he says, “is the really amazing thing, and that’s the difference between me and a real writer.”

He likes the Plath poem because it casts the surgeon in an ambiguous light. “Most writing about people in medicine casts them as either heroes or villains,” he says. “That poem captures the surgeon as a merely human, slightly bewildered, a little bit benighted person in a world that is ultimately beyond his control.”

I was given Gawande’s book, Better: A Surgeon’s Notes on Performance, which I doubt I would have bought and read on my own, and found it to be excellent. I especially like his stories about the time he spent working in India.

Though I’m obviously not in the medical profession, the Plath quote strikes a nerve right now. My little dog, Munchkin had a rather severe setback last week and had to be reopened (even with persistent flushing we couldn’t get all the dead flesh flushed out), cleaned out, and left with two fairly large openings in her abdomen so the stuff can drain. She’s now doing much better, but I am repeatedly (three times a day, flushing) looking at “jammy substances” as Plath puts it.

-Julie

http://www.unrealnature.com/

11 Comments

  1. Fave surgical poem:

    James Kirkup, A Correct Compassion
    to Mr. Philip Allison, after watching him perform a Mistral Stenosis Valvulotomy in the General Infirmary in Leeds

    Comment by Ray Girvan — September 1, 2009 @ 12:47 pm

  2. A Mitral Stenosis Valvulatomy. Unless perhaps the patient is suffering from wind.

    Comment by Ray Girvan — September 1, 2009 @ 12:49 pm

  3. Sorry – typing in half-dark here. Only Mitral supposed to be emphasised.

    Comment by Ray Girvan — September 1, 2009 @ 12:50 pm

  4. That is excellent. Because of the “fave” intro, I was expecting … satire, but it’s not that at all. Pure drama.

    [Also, at the top of Ray’s linked page, the phrase, “one of those stately morbid American poets” made me laugh. Yes, we have quite a few of those … ]

    I also was thinking that there couldn’t be too much competition for “fave” surgical poem, but Googling gets a lot of results. Most of them strange and not very good, but I guess there are lots of poems about everything.

    Among Google’s results was a book, Hip-Hop-Perations, which I think I should recommend to Dr. C.

    Comment by unrealnature — September 1, 2009 @ 2:49 pm

  5. Emily Dickinson: “Surgeons must be very careful”

    Surgeons must be very careful
    When they take the knife!
    Underneath their fine incisions
    Stirs the Culprit — Life!

    Wish I had access here

    Comment by Ray Girvan — September 1, 2009 @ 3:22 pm

  6. I’ve always felt that the lines from Plath’s The sculptor:

    SP> Hands moving move priestlier
    SP> Than priest’s hands…

    …somehow belong in The surgeon at 2am.

    A student recently pointed me to this page.

    Comment by Felix Grant — September 1, 2009 @ 4:19 pm

  7. Wish I had access
    Ah, found the piece in Vignettes on Surgery, History and Humanities (PDF. Interesting overall, but the poetry segment is pretty thin.

    Comment by Ray Girvan — September 2, 2009 @ 9:55 am

  8. That’s a really good, quick overview of the history of surgery. The main author really likes what he does (see the chapter titled “The Soul of the Knife”).

    I’m puzzling over the last chapter, Intellectual Honesty. How is that different from “regular” honesty?

    What the author is actually grumping about is people who plagiarise — by not using proper footnotes; or what he, via Garfield (properly footnoted)calls “citation amnesia.”

    Comment by unrealnature — September 2, 2009 @ 2:55 pm

  9. JH Intellectual Honesty. How is
    JH that different from “regular” honesty?

    Good question. My first reaction to it was impatience: I know exactly what intellectual honesty is, in relation to “regular” honesty. On trying to explain this self evident and obvious thing, however, I find that it’s not so easy.

    Hmmm…

    Comment by Felix Grant — September 2, 2009 @ 5:01 pm

  10. I’d interpret it as readiness to internally “audit”, to make effort to recognise and avoid one’s own cognitive biases.

    Comment by Ray Girvan — September 2, 2009 @ 6:22 pm

  11. In view of what the chapter is about, my guess would be that the author was looking for an antonym for plagiarism (intellectual dishonesty).

    Comment by unrealnature — September 2, 2009 @ 7:02 pm


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Blog at WordPress.com.